Updated March 2026
| 1 | Alan Shearer Blackburn/Newcastle | 441 apps | 260 goals |
| 2 | Wayne Rooney Everton/Man Utd | 491 apps | 208 goals |
| 3 | Andrew Cole Newcastle/Man Utd + | 414 apps | 187 goals |
| 4 | Sergio Aguero Man City | 275 apps | 0.67 per game | 184 goals |
| 5 | Frank Lampard West Ham/Chelsea/Man City | Midfielder! | 177 goals |
| 6 | Thierry Henry Arsenal | 258 apps | The King | 175 goals |
| 7 | Robbie Fowler Liverpool/Leeds/Man City | 163 goals |
| 8 | Jermain Defoe West Ham/Spurs/Sunderland + | 162 goals |
| 9 | Michael Owen Liverpool/Man Utd/Newcastle | 150 goals |
| 10 | Harry Kane Spurs | Now at Bayern Munich | 320 apps | 213 goals |